Loan types
Fixed vs adjustable-rate mortgage: which fits your plans
One keeps the rate the same for the whole loan. The other starts lower, then moves. What matters is how long you will keep it.
By AbodePine Editorial Team Updated 8 min read
- Fixed-rate loan
- Rate never changes
- Hybrid ARM, such as 5/1
- 5 years fixed, then yearly
- First-change notice
- 210 to 240 days ahead
- Year-6 example range
- $1,811 to $2,374
In brief
A fixed-rate mortgage keeps the same rate, so principal and interest stay level for the life of the loan. An adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) has a fixed introductory period, then the rate moves with the market, and CFPB warns the payment could go up a lot, even double. In the example below, a 5/1 ARM saves about $105 a month for five years and then could cost anywhere from $180 less to $383 more a month than the starting payment. Decide by how long you will keep the loan, and what you would do if the payment rose.
How each type works
With a fixed-rate loan the rate does not change. CFPB notes that the principal and interest payment stays level, though your total monthly payment can still move if property taxes, homeowners insurance or mortgage insurance change (see what's in your mortgage payment).
Most ARMs are hybrids: a fixed-rate introductory period, then a period when the rate adjusts. In CFPB's adjustable-rate booklet, a "5/1" ARM means the first number is how long the initial rate and payment last (five years) and the second is how often the rate changes after that (every year). When it adjusts, the new rate is an index (a measure of general interest-rate trends) plus a margin (a fixed percentage the lender adds), subject to caps that limit how far the rate can move. The booklet, last updated in June 2020, names the U.S. prime rate and the Constant Maturity Treasury rate as common indexes and says lenders' indexes differ.
Page 1 of the Loan Estimate shows whether the rate or the principal and interest payment can rise after closing. CFPB also says to look there for a prepayment penalty or a balloon payment, and to ask for a comparison estimate without the feature if you see one.
A worked example
Take a $315,000 loan, the same one as in how much house you can afford. Every rate and cap below is an example, not a quote. The fixed loan is 30 years at 7.0%. The ARM is a 5/1 at an example 6.5% for the first five years, with example caps of 2 points at the first adjustment, 2 at each later adjustment and 5 over the starting rate. After 60 payments the ARM balance is about $294,875, and the new payment is figured on that balance over the remaining 25 years (300 months), using payment = loan × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n).
| Scenario | Rate | Payment |
|---|---|---|
| 30-year fixed, any year | 7.0% | $2,096 |
| 5/1 ARM, years 1 to 5 | 6.5% | $1,991 ($105 below fixed) |
| ARM, year 6, rate falls 1 point | 5.5% | $1,811 ($180 below the ARM start) |
| ARM, year 6, rate rises 2 points (first-change cap) | 8.5% | $2,374 ($383 above the ARM start) |
| ARM, if it reached the 5-point cap | 11.5% | About $2,997 ($1,006 above the ARM start) |
The ARM's saving is about $6,300 over the first five years ($105 × 60). If the rate rises 2 points in year 6, the ARM costs $278 a month more than the fixed loan ($2,374 minus $2,096), and the $6,300 saved is used up in about 23 months ($6,300 ÷ $278). The last row is shown on the same balance to keep the arithmetic simple; a real payment that late would be a little lower on a smaller balance. The point is the shape: the downside can be larger than the saving.
Caps, notices and questions to ask
Federal rules give you warning before a rate change. For the first adjustment that changes the payment, the lender or servicer must send a notice at least 210 and no more than 240 days before the first adjusted payment is due. For later adjustments the window is generally 60 to 120 days (shorter for loans that adjust every 60 days or more often). The notice shows the current and new rate and payment, how the rate is set (the index and margin), the limits, and alternatives such as refinancing, selling or modifying the loan, with a phone number and counseling resources. If the new figures are only estimates, another notice with actual numbers follows two to four months before the payment is due.
- How high can my interest rate go, and how high can my payment go?
- How long is my starting payment fixed, and how often does it adjust after that?
- What index is used, where is it published and what is the margin?
- Is the starting rate lower than the fully indexed rate? That is what the rate would be if the introductory period ended now.
- What do the adjustment notices say, and is there a prepayment penalty?
Which one fits your plans
CFPB says an ARM can be cheaper early on and may suit someone who plans to move during the initial fixed period, and that if you stay longer than planned you could end up paying a lot more. It suggests estimating the shortest, most likely and longest time you will keep the loan, and asking a loan officer or a housing counselor to calculate total costs over each.
Do not count on refinancing as the exit. CFPB says refinancing is not guaranteed: a drop in income or in the home's value could prevent it, and rising rates could remove its benefit. A fixed rate fits best when you plan to stay several years or when a payment that moves would strain your budget. An ARM fits best when you have a credible plan to leave or to pay off the loan inside the fixed period, and room in your budget to absorb the worst-case row in the table.
Qualifying can differ too. Fannie Mae's guide sets a 640 minimum score for manually underwritten ARMs against 620 for fixed-rate loans, and lenders may set their own rules. Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year fixed average at 7.28% for the week of November 19, 2026, but it stopped reporting ARM rates in November 2022, so there is no public benchmark to compare an ARM against. Compare Loan Estimates for both types from the same lenders instead.
- Estimate your shortest, most likely and longest time in the home.
- Ask three lenders for a Loan Estimate for a fixed-rate loan and for an ARM, with the caps spelled out.
- Run the worst-case payment in the mortgage payment calculator and ask whether your budget survives it.
- Check the points and lender credits guide before comparing rates, since a lower rate can come with an upfront cost.
Questions people ask
What does 5/1 ARM mean?
In CFPB's booklet the first number is how long the starting rate and payment last, here five years. The second is how often the rate can change after that, here every year.
Can an ARM payment go down?
Yes, if the index falls and your loan terms allow it. The booklet says an ARM's rate is generally never below the margin, so ask what the lowest possible rate is for your loan.
How much notice will I get before my ARM changes?
For the first adjustment that changes your payment, the lender or servicer must send a notice 210 to 240 days before the first adjusted payment is due. For later adjustments it is generally 60 to 120 days.
Is an ARM always cheaper than a fixed-rate loan?
No. CFPB says ARMs can be cheaper early on, but the payment can rise later. Freddie Mac no longer publishes ARM rates, so compare Loan Estimates from your lenders for the same loan amount.
Sources
- CFPB — Understand the different kinds of loans available
- CFPB — Select the kind of loan that fits your needs
- CFPB — Request and review multiple Loan Estimates
- CFPB — Consumer Handbook on Adjustable-Rate Mortgages (last updated June 2020)
- CFPB — Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.20 (adjustable-rate notices)
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide — B3-5.1-01, General Requirements for Credit Scores
- Freddie Mac — Primary Mortgage Market Survey
The $315,000 loan and all rates and caps are examples chosen for the arithmetic, not quotes or averages. The Freddie Mac survey figure (7.28%) is for the week of November 19, 2026. Your loan documents set your own index, margin and caps. Facts on this page were checked against these sources on November 20, 2026.
Next to read
-
Buying guide
Mortgage points and lender credits
Trade cash today for a lower rate, or the reverse. How to run the break-even before you pay.
-
Buying guide
Conventional loans and PMI
What a conventional loan needs, which programs allow 3% down, and when PMI has to end.
-
Owning guide
When to refinance
Divide the costs by the monthly saving to see how long a refinance takes to pay off.