Commissions
Agent commissions after the NAR settlement: what you negotiate now
The rule that tied listings to an offer of pay for the buyer's agent is gone from the MLS. What remains is a negotiation, and you are one of the people in it.
By AbodePine Editorial Team Updated 7 min read
- MLS changes took effect
- August 17, 2024
- Commission is set by
- Your written agreement
- Average commission
- No official figure
- Appeals court decision
- Aug 19, 2026
In brief
After lawsuits over how buyer's agents were paid, the National Association of Realtors (NAR) announced practice changes that took effect on August 17, 2024: an offer of pay to a buyer's agent can no longer be made through the MLS, and buyers sign a written agreement before touring. A federal appeals court upheld the settlement on August 19, 2026. No official average commission exists. The rate is what you and your agent agree in writing. On a $400,000 sale, each percentage point is $4,000.
What changed, and who says so
Lawsuits claimed that NAR's rules, which tied listings on a local listing service (the MLS) to an offer of compensation for the buyer's broker, pushed commissions up. Court records note that the defendants deny the allegations. NAR settled, and the settlement has since been approved by the courts.
Here is NAR's own account. In an article of May 3, 2024, NAR said it would end any requirement of offers of compensation in the MLS and prohibit participants and subscribers from making such offers there. It also said MLS participants working with a buyer must enter a written agreement with the buyer before touring a home, and that compensation must be disclosed to sellers, prospective sellers and prospective buyers. NAR set August 17, 2024 as the effective date. NAR's FAQ page confirms that date and ties the written-agreement requirement to touring a home.
The federal Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit described the settlement's terms in its opinion of August 19, 2026. Sellers are no longer obligated to offer compensation to buyer's brokers in MLS listings. Any offer of buyer-broker compensation, if made at all, must be disclosed to and approved by sellers in advance. Buyer's brokers must sign written agreements before touring homes, and the agreements must disclose the broker's fee, identify who pays it and bar fees above the buyer's agreed sum. Buyer's brokers can no longer steer buyers toward listings based on commission level, and brokers must tell clients that commissions are negotiable.
| Date | What happened | Source |
|---|---|---|
| April 23, 2024 | Preliminary court approval of the NAR settlement | NAR article, May 3, 2024 |
| August 17, 2024 | NAR's practice changes take effect | NAR article and FAQ page |
| November 26, 2024 | Final settlement approval conference held in the Western District of Missouri | Court's case page |
| January 15, 2025 | Final judgment entered for NAR | District court judgment |
| August 19, 2026 | Eighth Circuit affirms the approval of the settlement | Eighth Circuit opinion |
What it means when you list
You now have two separate money questions. One is the fee to your own listing brokerage. The other is whether you will offer anything toward the buyer's broker. Neither one is set by law, and the changes above do not set a rate. The court's description says brokers must tell you commissions are negotiable.
Arithmetic helps you compare offers. On a $400,000 sale, one percentage point is $4,000, so every quarter point is $1,000. The table shows what different total rates would cost. These are examples, not typical or recommended rates.
| Total commission (example) | Dollars | Left of the price, before other costs |
|---|---|---|
| 3% | $12,000 | $388,000 |
| 4% | $16,000 | $384,000 |
| 5% | $20,000 | $380,000 |
| 6% | $24,000 | $376,000 |
If you split the total, add the parts. Suppose you agree to 2.5% for your own brokerage and decide to offer 2% toward a buyer's broker. That is 4.5% in total, or $18,000 on $400,000. A buyer who arrives with a written agreement may ask you to cover some or all of their broker's fee. You can say yes, no or something in between, and you should know your number before the question comes. A concession to a buyer, such as a credit at closing, is a related but separate tool, and it reduces your proceeds in the same way a fee does.
Questions to ask before you sign a listing agreement
- What is your fee for the listing side, as a percentage or a flat amount, and what does it include: photos, advertising, staging, open houses?
- Do you recommend offering anything toward a buyer's broker, how much, and what is your reason?
- What happens to the fee if the buyer has no agent, or if I find the buyer myself?
- How long does the agreement run, and how can I end it if I am unhappy?
- Is any part of the fee or other cost payable even if the home does not sell?
- Can you show me the sales behind your suggested list price?
Convert each answer into dollars on your expected price, so that a percentage from one agent and a flat fee from another can be compared on the same line. Fees that look close can differ by thousands once the buyer's side is included.
Get every answer in writing, and compare at least two agents. A listing agreement is a contract. A real estate attorney licensed in your state can read it before you sign, which is worth considering if any term is unclear.
Commission, taxes and your net
For tax purposes the commission is a selling expense. IRS Publication 523 lists sales commissions, advertising fees and legal fees among the costs directly associated with selling, and it figures your amount realized as the sale price minus selling expenses. That amount, not the sale price, is what you compare with your basis when you figure a gain. Whether any gain is taxed depends on the home-sale exclusion and your other facts; see capital gains tax on a home sale.
For the cash you will actually receive, subtract the commission, your mortgage payoff and the other costs of selling from the price. Seller closing costs and net proceeds walks through that sheet. To decide the price itself, start with pricing your home. If you are also buying, the buyer's side of the same negotiation is in making an offer and earnest money.
Questions people ask
Is the commission still 6%?
Nothing sets it. No law, agency or settlement term fixes a rate or publishes an official average, and the court describes commissions as negotiable. Ask each agent for the fee in writing.
Who pays the buyer's agent now?
It is negotiated. NAR's changes take offers of compensation out of the MLS. The court's description adds that any offer from a seller must be disclosed to and approved by the seller in advance, and the buyer's written agreement must say the broker's fee and who pays it.
Can I still offer to pay part of the buyer's agent's fee?
The court's description says offers of buyer-broker compensation, if made at all, need to be approved by the seller in advance. Whether you make one is your decision. NAR says such offers cannot be made in the MLS itself.
Do these changes apply where I live?
NAR said REALTOR-owned MLSs had to apply the changes by August 17, 2024, and MLSs that opted into the settlement had until September 16, 2024. Ask your agent how your local MLS handles them.
Was the settlement upheld on appeal?
Yes. The Eighth Circuit affirmed the district court's approval of the settlement in an opinion filed August 19, 2026.
Sources
- NAR — NAR Practice Changes to Take Effect Aug. 17 (May 3, 2024)
- NAR — Settlement FAQs
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit — Burnett v. National Association of Realtors, opinion filed August 19, 2026
- U.S. District Court, Western District of Missouri — Final Judgment (NAR), January 15, 2025
- U.S. District Court, Western District of Missouri — Burnett et al v. National Association of Realtors et al
- IRS — Publication 523, Selling Your Home (2025)
NAR is a trade association, and the NAR items above are NAR's account of its own practice changes; the court items are the courts' own documents. The $400,000 price and the 2.5%, 2%, 3%, 4%, 5% and 6% rates are examples for the arithmetic, not averages or recommendations. Facts on this page were checked against these sources on November 20, 2026.
Next to read
-
Selling guide
Seller closing costs and net proceeds
What comes out of your sale price at closing, with a worked example of the cash you keep.
-
Selling guide
Pricing your home
Build a list price from comps and competition, then test it against a buyer's monthly payment.
-
Buying guide
Making an offer and earnest money
What goes into an offer, how the deposit works, and the contingencies that protect it.