Skip to content
AbodePine

Shopping

How to compare homeowners insurance quotes fairly

Two quotes with different prices are rarely quotes for the same policy. Fix the coverage first, then compare the cost.

By AbodePine Editorial Team Updated 6 min read

First rule
Same terms in every quote
Then compare
Four terms, then price
Get it in writing
Yes, every quote
Example gap
$300 a year vs $3,500
Illustration: two insurance quote sheets side by side with a checklist

In brief

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) says it is crucial to ask for the same coverages and limits when you get quotes. Build one written list of what you want, send it to every insurer or agent, and compare four things beyond price: the dwelling limit, how the deductible works, the endorsements (add-ons) and the exclusions. In the example below, a quote that is $300 a year cheaper could cost $3,500 more when you file a claim.

Start with one coverage list

A quote is a price for a specific set of terms. If one insurer assumes a higher dwelling limit, a lower deductible or an extra add-on, its price is not comparable with another's. The NAIC's consumer guide to home insurance puts it plainly: "When you get quotes, it's crucial that you ask for the same coverages and limits." It also says to get rate quotes and key information in writing. The guide is the 2022 edition.

So decide your terms before you ask anyone. The guide to how much homeowners insurance you need covers the dwelling limit, and what homeowners insurance covers explains the parts of a policy. Write your choices on one page, send the same page to every insurer or agent you contact, and ask for the answer in writing. If you have a mortgage, ask your lender whether it sets minimum coverage before you settle on limits.

Four things to match before you look at price

What to line up across quotes
TermWhat to askWhy it changes the price
Dwelling limitHow much the policy pays to rebuild the houseNAIC: the dwelling limit should cover the cost to fully rebuild, which is not the same as market value.
How losses are paidReplacement cost or actual cash valueActual cash value usually costs less in premium but often pays too little to fully repair or replace.
DeductibleA dollar amount or a percentage, and for which lossesA higher deductible means a lower premium; some areas use percentage deductibles for catastrophes.
EndorsementsWhich add-ons are included, and their limitsSewer or drain backup, scheduled personal property and similar coverage are added by endorsement.
ExclusionsWhat the policy does not coverFlood and earthquake are commonly excluded and need separate coverage.

The NAIC says coverage below 80% of full replacement cost may reduce claim payments, so a quote built on a low dwelling limit can look cheap and still leave a gap. It also notes that coastal policies often exclude windstorm and hail, which may require a separate policy, and that mold and sewer or drain backup coverage are often limited or unavailable. Ask each insurer to state these in the quote, not in a phone call. A state example points the same way: the California Department of Insurance's homeowners guide (revised January 2026) warns against comparing prices without comparing coverage, tells readers to read the exclusions, and lists flood, earthquake, mold, and wear and tear among the perils usually excluded. For flood, see flood insurance.

A worked example

Say you ask two insurers to cover the same house with a $300,000 dwelling limit. These are made-up numbers for the arithmetic, not quotes or averages. Quote A is $1,800 a year with a $2,500 flat deductible. Quote B is $1,500 a year with a deductible of 2% of the dwelling limit, which is 2% × $300,000 = $6,000.

  • Premium difference: $1,800 − $1,500 = $300 a year in B's favor.
  • Deductible difference on a covered claim: $6,000 − $2,500 = $3,500 more out of your pocket with B.
  • Break-even: $3,500 ÷ $300 is about 11.7 years without a claim before B's savings repay the larger deductible.

Quote B is not wrong, and for some households it is the right trade. The point is that the lower price came from a different deductible, and you only see that if you ask how the deductible is defined. The NAIC's consumer insight page notes a deductible may be a percentage of the home's insured value, and that you should be sure you can afford it if you have a loss. Run your own two quotes through the deductible trade-off calculator, and see choosing a deductible for the longer discussion.

Check the company, then the discounts

Once the terms match, price is a fair comparison. The NAIC guide suggests checking a company's financial strength with ratings from agencies such as Standard & Poor's, A.M. Best and Moody's, and looking at a state complaint index, which shows how many complaints your state insurance department receives compared with the company's size. It also says to confirm that the insurer and the agent are licensed. Your state insurance department is the place to verify a license and ask about complaints.

Ask about discounts last, so they do not blur the comparison. The NAIC guide lists examples: bundling auto and home, storm shutters, updated electrical or plumbing, a new roof and security devices. A discount is a reason to re-run the numbers, not a reason to skip the coverage list. A national average is also a poor yardstick. The NAIC's report puts the countrywide average premium for a standard HO-3 policy at $1,737 for data year 2023 (published July 2026), but your own price depends on your home, its location and the terms above.

A simple order of work

  1. Write one coverage list: dwelling limit, how losses are paid, deductibles, add-ons you want and anything you plan to cover separately.
  2. Send that list to each insurer or agent and ask for written quotes on those terms.
  3. Put the quotes in one table and mark every place where a quote differs from your list.
  4. Ask about discounts, then check each company's license, financial rating and complaint record with your state insurance department.
  5. Choose on price only among quotes that match. If you are unsure what a term means, ask before you sign.

If your premium rose at renewal and you are shopping because of it, read why your premium went up first. It may point to a term you can change without switching insurers.

Questions people ask

Why are two homeowners insurance quotes so different?

Often they describe different policies: another dwelling limit, a different deductible type, or add-ons included in one and not the other. Match the terms before you compare the prices.

Should I choose the quote with the lowest premium?

Only after the coverage matches. A lower premium can come from a higher deductible, a lower dwelling limit or payment at actual cash value, any of which can cost more when you file a claim.

How many quotes should I get?

No official number exists. Get enough that you can see how the same list of terms is priced by more than one insurer, and keep each one in writing.

Where do I check that an insurer is licensed?

Your state insurance department. The NAIC says it is illegal for unlicensed insurers or agents to sell insurance, and the department can also tell you about complaints.

Sources

The $300,000 dwelling limit, both premiums and both deductibles are examples chosen for the arithmetic, not quotes or averages. Policy terms vary by insurer and state. Facts on this page were checked against these sources on November 20, 2026.