Premiums
Why your homeowners insurance premium went up
A higher renewal bill has two kinds of causes: things happening across the market and things that changed on your own policy. Sort out which one you have.
By AbodePine Editorial Team Updated 6 min read
- Average HO-3 premium
- $1,737 (2023 data)
- Market-wide drivers
- Disasters, inflation
- Your levers
- Deductible, limits
- Where to complain
- State insurance dept.
In brief
Premiums rise when catastrophe losses, inflation and the cost of rebuilding rise across the market, and also when something changes on your own policy, such as a higher dwelling limit, a claim or a lost discount. The NAIC's latest figure, an average of $1,737 for the HO-3 in 2023 data, cannot tell you what your bill will do next. Compare this year's declarations page with last year's, then ask the insurer to explain the difference line by line.
Start by comparing two pages
Pull last year's and this year's declarations page, the summary at the front of the policy that lists the limits, deductibles and premium. Put them side by side. Did the dwelling limit change? Did the deductible? Did a discount disappear, or an endorsement (an add-on) get added? A premium that rose because your limit rose is a different problem from one that rose with the same coverage.
Also check who is billing you. If a mortgage servicer pays the premium from escrow, the servicer's statement shows the amount it paid or plans to pay, and the insurer's renewal notice shows what was billed. If the two do not match, call both before you assume anything is wrong.
Then ask the insurer or agent for a plain explanation of the change. Ask what part is a rate change that applies to many policyholders, and what part is specific to your home, your claims history or your coverage choices. Write down the answer and the date.
What is moving the whole market
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), the group of state insurance regulators, says in its homeowners report that catastrophes are a significant consideration in pricing home insurance. It also says inflation increases premiums over time and that the cost to repair or replace more expensive materials has affected them. It adds that stricter building codes may reduce premiums over the long run.
None of that is something you can change by calling your agent. The report's figure is also old by the time it is published: the countrywide average HO-3 premium was $1,737 for data year 2023, in a report published in July 2026. It describes one year, not a trend line for your state, so do not read it as a forecast of your own renewal.
A practical way to use this: when the explanation you get is a general rate change, your leverage is limited to the policy choices below. When it is specific to you, such as a lost discount or an outdated rating detail, there may be something to correct, so ask what proof the insurer needs.
What is specific to you
The NAIC's consumer guide lists the factors that affect an individual premium. Some are in your hands and some are not. The guide also says claims can affect your premium and renewal, so ask how a past claim is counted and for how long.
| Reason | In your control? | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Higher dwelling limit or new endorsements | Yes | Which change added how much? |
| Lower deductible than before | Yes | What would a higher one change? |
| A claim or claims history | Partly | How long does this claim count? |
| Credit history, where state law allows | Partly | Is it used here, and can it be re-run? |
| Roof age, home condition, nearby hazards | Partly | What would update the rating? |
| Lost bundling or protective-device discount | Yes | Which discounts do I still get? |
The guide also lists rebuild cost, construction type, age and condition, distance to water and to fire services, pools, trampolines and wood stoves, certain dog breeds and a home business. Insurers may offer discounts for bundling auto coverage, smoke and burglar alarms, sprinklers, deadbolts, storm shutters, updated electrical or plumbing, and a new roof. Ask directly; the guide says to.
What you can do about it
A higher bill is a prompt to review the policy, not just to pay it. Work through this list in order, because the first steps cost nothing.
- Check that the dwelling limit matches a current rebuild estimate, not a guess (see how much homeowners insurance you need).
- Ask for every discount you may qualify for, and send proof of any update you have made, such as a new roof.
- Price a higher deductible, but only if you could pay it in cash tomorrow (see choosing a deductible).
- Get comparable quotes for the same coverage and limits, and compare line by line (see comparing homeowners quotes).
- Do not drop coverage you need, such as dwelling or liability, only to hit a price.
A deductible is the part of a loss you pay before the insurer pays, and the NAIC says a lower deductible means a higher premium. Moving to a higher one is the quickest lever, with a cost: you carry more of every loss. The other levers have costs too. Dropping an endorsement saves premium but removes the cover, and a lower dwelling limit saves premium but can push you under the 80% test the NAIC describes. A smaller bill is only a good result if the policy still does the job you bought it for.
What it does to your monthly payment
If your insurance is paid through a mortgage escrow account, the CFPB says the monthly payment can change when those costs change. As an example, a $2,400 premium that rises 10% goes up by $240 a year ($2,400 × 0.10), which is $20 a month ($240 ÷ 12). The numbers are an example, not a forecast. The escrow side of this is in escrow accounts explained.
If you cannot resolve a dispute about a rate, a cancellation or a non-renewal with the insurer, your state insurance department takes complaints. The NAIC says to try the insurer first, then contact the department, and to bring your policy documents and a dated log of your conversations. The weekly email, The Doorstep, also covers owner costs now and then.
Questions people ask
Why did my premium go up when I never filed a claim?
Market-wide costs can raise rates for everyone, and changes to your limit, coverage or discounts can raise yours. The NAIC says catastrophes, inflation and costlier materials all affect premiums.
Does filing a claim raise my premium?
It can. The NAIC's consumer guide says claims can affect your premium and renewal, which is one reason to think before filing a small one. Ask your insurer how it treats claims before you decide.
Will shopping around lower my premium?
It might, or it might not. Quotes for the same coverage and limits can differ, so compare like with like, and do not give up needed coverage to get a lower number.
Who regulates homeowners insurance rates?
Your state insurance department. How rate changes and non-renewals are handled differs by state, so look up your state's department through the NAIC directory.
Sources
- NAIC — Homeowners Insurance Report (data year 2023, published July 2026)
- NAIC — A Consumer's Guide to Home Insurance (2022 edition)
- NAIC — Homeowners Insurance (Insurance Topics)
- NAIC — How to file an insurance complaint
- CFPB — What is an escrow or impound account?
The $2,400 premium and 10% increase are examples chosen for the arithmetic, not data or a forecast. AbodePine is not an insurer or agent and does not quote prices. Facts on this page were checked against these sources on November 20, 2026.
Next to read
-
Insurance or warranty guide
Comparing homeowners quotes
Match the dwelling limit, deductible type, add-ons and exclusions before you compare prices.
-
Insurance or warranty guide
Choosing a deductible
Flat or percentage, and the break-even arithmetic for a higher deductible.
-
Owning guide
Escrow accounts explained
How your lender collects tax and insurance, why the payment changes and what a shortage means.