Warranty
How to choose a home warranty: what to read first
This guide does not rank companies. It shows what to check in any contract so you can compare plans yourself.
By AbodePine Editorial Team Updated 6 min read
- Read before paying
- The full contract
- Check first
- Is the seller licensed?
- Ranking here
- None
- Report problems
- ReportFraud.ftc.gov
In brief
Get the full written contract before you pay and read it for exclusions, caps per item, the service-call fee, who picks the repair company, cancellation, pre-existing conditions and how a denial is appealed. Confirm with your state regulator that the seller is licensed where licensing is required, and run the price through the break-even math. This site does not name or rank warranty companies.
Decide what you need covered
Start with your house, not the plan. List the appliances and systems you own, roughly how old each is and what a repair would cost. California's insurance regulator makes a plain point: a plan that covers air conditioning or a pool costs more, so it is not worth paying for if you have neither. A plan that fits your house is easier to judge than a long list of features.
Then decide whether a plan makes sense at all. The arithmetic is in is a home warranty worth it, and what a home warranty covers explains the basics of a service contract. Check for overlap with warranties you already hold, because the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) warns that a plan may duplicate coverage you already have.
Confirm the seller is licensed
Home warranty regulation differs by state, and a few examples show how. California's Department of Insurance says it regulates and licenses these companies, lets you check a license by phone, and posts a list of licensed companies and a summary of consumer complaints it has investigated. It also warns that some companies have sold warranties in California without a license. The Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation licenses sellers there and tells consumers to check whether the company is licensed before buying. Florida requires anyone who sells or solicits home warranties in or from the state to be licensed.
Your state may work differently; ask your state insurance department or attorney general's consumer protection office who oversees these contracts. Florida's page adds two checks worth copying: confirm the company's full legal name, often shown as "underwritten by" or the "obligor," and keep your receipts and warranty documents together.
Read the contract, not the brochure
Ask for the complete contract in writing before you pay, and read it against the list below. Each item is something the FTC, California or Texas tells buyers to check.
| Look for | The question to answer |
|---|---|
| Exclusions | Which appliances and systems are left out, and is accidental damage covered? |
| Caps per item | What is the most the plan pays for one repair, one item and one year? |
| Service-call fee | What do you pay each time a technician visits? |
| Who picks the contractor | Can you choose the repair company, or must you use theirs? |
| Response time | How fast will repairs be made? California requires the contract to represent that services will start within 48 hours. |
| Pre-existing conditions | Does a problem that existed before the contract started void coverage? |
| Maintenance | Can the company deny a claim over missed maintenance, and what proof does it ask for? |
| Cancellation and renewal | What are the restrictions and fees for ending the contract, and how is the renewal price set? |
| Denials | How is a denied claim appealed, and who decides? |
Two items deserve extra attention because they decide whether the price means anything. The first is the cap: Texas's agency tells buyers to ask for the maximum payout limits, and California's tells them to read the dollar limits on what the company will pay. A plan that stops paying well below the cost of replacing a major item is worth less than its price suggests. The second is the pre-existing condition clause, which Texas's agency says to ask about. If you are buying a house, the inspection report is your record of what was wrong on day one (see home inspection and appraisal).
To compare two plans, copy the table above into a sheet, one column per plan, and fill it from the contracts themselves. Where a contract is silent, write "not stated" and ask the company to answer in writing. A blank is a reason to ask, not a reason to assume the answer you would like.
Several of these are state matters. Florida, for example, requires exclusions in boldface and says a buyer who cancels within 10 days can get a refund of the gross premium less claims paid and an administrative fee of up to 5%. Do not assume your state gives the same rights; ask your regulator or read the contract's state notice.
Check reputation, then run the numbers
The FTC suggests searching the company name with words like "review" or "complaint." Treat reviews as opinions and look for patterns, such as repeated complaints about delays or denials, then ask the company about those points in writing. California's regulator advises reviewing a company's performance and complaint data on its public website, and the FTC's page on service contracts adds checking complaints on file with your state consumer protection office.
Put a number on cost. Divide the total cost by the length of the contract to get a yearly figure, add the service fee for each visit you expect, and run it through the home warranty break-even calculator. Set the share the plan pays below 100% if the contract's caps and exclusions suggest some claims will not be paid in full.
Beware pressure to buy fast
The FTC warns that marketers may contact you years after a purchase, often with no connection to the original seller, with lines such as "act now, your warranty is about to expire." Be wary of anyone who asks for personal, financial or first-payment information before explaining the terms. If a call or mail is unsolicited, hang up or set it aside and look up a company yourself. A contract worth buying will still be there after you have read it.
If you later run into a problem, report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to your state's regulator. The steps for a denied claim are in home warranty claims and denials.
Questions people ask
How do I find a reputable home warranty company?
No agency names a recommended company. Confirm the license where your state requires one, read the full contract, search the company's name with "review" or "complaint," and check complaint records with your state regulator.
What should I look for in a home warranty contract?
Exclusions, caps per item, the service-call fee, who picks the contractor, pre-existing condition rules, cancellation terms, and how a denial is appealed.
Can I cancel a home warranty?
Contracts set their own cancellation terms, and the FTC tells buyers to check for restrictions and fees. Some states add rules; Florida's page describes a 10-day refund window for contracts there. Read yours before you pay.
Who regulates home warranties in my state?
It varies. California's Department of Insurance licenses them, Texas uses its Department of Licensing and Regulation, and other states differ. Ask your state insurance department or attorney general.
Sources
- FTC — So what's the deal with home warranties? (February 24, 2023)
- FTC — Extended Warranties and Service Contracts
- California Department of Insurance — Home Protection Contracts
- Florida Department of Financial Services — Home Warranty Overview
- Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation — What Should I Know About Residential Service Contracts? (January 2025)
State examples come from the California, Florida and Texas agencies named above and are not a survey of all states; the California and Florida pages show no update date. AbodePine does not sell, rank or recommend warranty companies. Facts on this page were checked against these sources on November 20, 2026.
Next to read
-
Insurance or warranty guide
Warranty claims and denials
Why plans deny claims, and the steps to take if yours is denied, from appeal to state regulator.
-
Insurance or warranty guide
Is a home warranty worth it?
Plan price and fees against the repairs you expect, with worked break-even examples.
-
Buying guide
Home inspection and appraisal
Who each check is for, what to do with the results, and your right to see the appraisal.