Warranty
Is a home warranty worth it? Do the break-even math
There is no yes or no for every house. There is arithmetic, and it takes a few minutes.
By AbodePine Editorial Team Updated 6 min read
- Break-even formula
- Price ÷ (repair − fee)
- Example plan
- $500 a year, $75 a visit
- Break-even, example
- 1.5 repairs a year
- If 75% paid
- 2.2 repairs a year
In brief
A home warranty is worth it only if the repairs it pays for in a year cost more than the plan price plus your service fees, after counting the claims it may deny. The FTC tells buyers to check whether a contract saves money overall. In the example below, a $500 plan with a $75 fee per visit breaks even at about 1.5 covered repairs a year when every claim is paid, and at about 2.2 when only three of four are.
Frame it as a cost comparison
A home warranty is a service contract, not insurance (see what a home warranty covers). You pay a plan price, usually for a year, and then a service fee each time you ask for a repair. In return the company repairs or replaces the items the contract covers. So the question is simple: in a typical year, do you pay less with the plan than you would pay for the same repairs yourself?
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) lists what to weigh: whether the contract saves you money overall, once deductibles and per-visit fees are counted; whether it has significant limits, such as caps, accidental damage, excluded systems and cancellation fees; whether the claims process is workable; and whether the company's reputation holds up. It also notes the coverage may duplicate what you already have. The first item is arithmetic. The rest decide whether the arithmetic holds.
The break-even arithmetic
For one year, with the plan you pay the plan price, plus the service fee on every request, plus the full repair cost of any request the plan denies. Without it, you pay each repair yourself. Each request the plan pays saves you the repair cost minus your service fee. So:
- Saving per paid request = repair cost × share of requests the plan pays − service fee.
- Break-even requests per year = plan price ÷ saving per request.
- If the saving per request is zero or negative, the plan never pays for itself.
Here are three examples. The $500 plan price, $75 fee, $400 and $1,500 repair costs and the shares paid are made up for the arithmetic. They are not quotes and not averages.
| Repair cost | Share paid | Saving per request | Break-even |
|---|---|---|---|
| $400 | 100% | $400 − $75 = $325 | $500 ÷ $325 ≈ 1.5 a year |
| $400 | 75% | $300 − $75 = $225 | $500 ÷ $225 ≈ 2.2 a year |
| $1,500 | 75% | $1,125 − $75 = $1,050 | $500 ÷ $1,050 ≈ 0.5 a year |
Read the rows this way. With a $400 repair and every claim paid, you need about one and a half covered repairs a year, so in practice two, to come out ahead. If one claim in four is denied, you need more. If the repair is $1,500, one covered claim every two years or so is enough. Cheap repairs make a plan hard to justify; expensive ones, paid reliably, make it easier. The home warranty break-even calculator runs your own numbers, including a lower share paid.
What moves the answer
- The share the plan pays. Caps per item, exclusions and denials all lower it. Estimate honestly after reading the contract, and see home warranty claims and denials for the usual reasons.
- The service fee. It is charged on each request. The higher it is relative to the repair cost, the more requests you need.
- What you already have. The FTC warns a plan may duplicate coverage you already hold. A new appliance may be under a manufacturer's warranty, and a new house may have a builder's warranty.
- The age and condition of the systems. Older equipment is more likely to need repair, but plans may refuse failures they call a pre-existing condition or a result of missed maintenance. A written inspection report helps you see what is already wrong; see home inspection and appraisal.
One input is hard to guess: how many repairs you will actually need. None of the official pages used for this guide gives a figure for it, and neither does this site, so do not borrow one from an ad. Use a range. Run the calculator with a good year (no repairs), a typical year and a bad year, and see how the plan does in each.
Contract limits matter here more than they seem to. Texas's licensing agency tells buyers to ask about the maximum payout limits, and California's regulator tells them to read the exclusions and dollar limits. If a plan pays only part of a $1,500 repair, treat it as a lower share paid in the calculator rather than a full paid claim.
Alternatives and a reasonable way to decide
The FTC's page on service contracts suggests an alternative: put the money you would spend on the contract in a savings account and use it for repairs. That page is about service contracts in general, but the logic carries over. If you keep a repair fund, the plan price is the cost of moving some risk to a company, and the service fee is what you pay for that service each time. The home maintenance budget guide shows ways to size such a fund.
A homeowners policy is a separate product that answers a different question; see home warranty vs homeowners insurance. If you do want a plan, how to choose a home warranty lists what to read in the contract. A plan tends to look better when the covered items are old and costly to fix, the fee is low, and the exclusions do not touch the systems you worry about. It looks worse when repairs are cheap, the fee is high, or the exclusions cover the systems you worry about.
Questions people ask
How do I know if a home warranty will pay for itself?
Divide the plan price by what each paid request saves you: the repair cost times the share the plan pays, minus the service fee. The result is the number of covered requests a year you need. Compare it with the repairs you realistically expect.
Do home warranty companies deny claims?
Plans can deny a claim under their terms, for example for pre-existing conditions, missed maintenance or excluded items. No official source reviewed here gives a denial rate, so build the risk into your estimate with the calculator's share-paid input.
Is a home warranty worth it for a new homeowner?
It depends on the age of the systems, the contract's exclusions and the price. A new home may already have a builder's warranty or manufacturer warranties, so check those first.
Is saving the money instead a better choice?
The FTC suggests it as an alternative for service contracts in general. A repair fund keeps unspent money, but you carry the risk of a large bill early on. Weigh both with the same arithmetic.
Sources
- FTC — So what's the deal with home warranties? (February 24, 2023)
- FTC — Extended Warranties and Service Contracts
- Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation — What Should I Know About Residential Service Contracts? (January 2025)
- California Department of Insurance — Home Protection Contracts
The $500 plan price, $75 service fee, $400 and $1,500 repair costs and the shares paid are examples chosen for the arithmetic, not quotes, averages or a prediction of how many repairs a home needs. Facts on this page were checked against these sources on November 20, 2026.
Next to read
-
Insurance or warranty guide
How to choose a home warranty
What to check in any plan: license, exclusions, caps, fees and how a denied claim is appealed.
-
Insurance or warranty guide
Warranty claims and denials
Why plans deny claims, and the steps to take if yours is denied, from appeal to state regulator.
-
Owning guide
Home maintenance budget
A 1% to 4% planning range, what Census data show, and a way to build your own number.