Value
CMA vs. appraisal: two opinions of value, two different jobs
An agent's CMA helps you choose a list price. An appraiser's report helps a lender decide whether the price fits the loan. Here is who orders each, and what happens when they disagree.
By AbodePine Editorial Team Updated 6 min read
- CMA
- An agent's price opinion
- Appraisal
- By a licensed appraiser
- Appraisal ordered by
- Often the buyer's lender
- Borrower's copy
- By 3 days before closing
In brief
A comparative market analysis (CMA) is an agent's opinion of what your home should sell for, built from recent sales. An appraisal is a licensed appraiser's written opinion, and in a financed sale the buyer's lender often relies on one. They can differ. If the appraisal lands below the contract price, the price, the cash or the deal has to change.
What each one is
A CMA is prepared by a real estate agent. It lists recent sales of similar homes near yours, often along with homes now for sale, and ends with a suggested list price or range. The CFPB describes a closely related product, the broker price opinion, as an estimate of value from a real estate sales professional, most often used to support a listing price. Its purpose is to help you and the agent decide where to start.
A CMA has no inspection standard behind it, and an agent competing for your listing has a reason to be generous about your home. You do not have to assume bad faith to protect yourself. Ask for the sales the number rests on, and judge those sales yourself.
The CFPB defines an appraisal as a written document that shows an opinion of how much a property is worth. A licensed appraiser inspects the property and adjusts for differences between the home and comparable sales, which are recent sales of similar homes nearby. States license and certify appraisers, and the federal Appraisal Subcommittee keeps a national registry of them. The CFPB also says lenders are not allowed to interfere with the appraiser's judgment.
If you suspect an appraisal was pressured, the Appraisal Subcommittee runs a hotline that refers complaints about appraisal independence to the right state or federal agency.
Side by side
| Question | CMA | Appraisal |
|---|---|---|
| Who prepares it | A real estate agent | A licensed appraiser |
| Main use | Choosing a list price | Supporting a loan or another formal need |
| Who orders it | You, or an agent hoping to list your home | Often the buyer's lender, in a financed sale |
| Who pays | Ask before you request one | The lender may require the borrower to pay |
| Who gets a copy | You; ask for the sales it used | The borrower, no later than three days before closing |
The CFPB says a lender may need a new appraisal when someone buys or refinances, and may require the borrower to pay for it. In a typical financed sale the buyer's lender orders it and may bill the buyer, not you. You still live with the result, because it can change the price.
Valuations also differ from each other. The CFPB says that is expected, since each is an estimate that may use different comps and be done at a different time or for a different purpose. When they differ a lot, the lender decides which one it considers most reliable.
When the appraisal comes in low
The CFPB's advice to buyers is blunt: paying more than the appraised value is very risky. It calls a low appraisal strong evidence that the price was above the home's market value, and it tells buyers to ask the seller to lower the price. If the seller refuses, a buyer may cancel the sale, with costs that depend on the contract. Expect that conversation if your price runs ahead of the comps.
Here is the arithmetic with example numbers. Your contract price is $400,000 and the appraisal is $380,000. The gap is $20,000, or 5% of the price. It can be closed by a price cut, by the buyer bringing more cash, by a split of the two, or the sale can fall through under the contract's terms. A $10,000 cut means $10,000 less in your proceeds. The buyer's lender decides how much it will lend against the appraised value, so the buyer cannot simply ignore the number.
If it happens to you, work through it in this order:
- Ask your agent whether the buyer will share the report, and read which sales the appraiser used.
- Compare them with your own comps. If a closer or more recent sale was missed, ask whether the buyer's lender will review it.
- Decide your walk-away number before you talk price, using your payoff and costs. Seller closing costs and net proceeds shows the subtraction.
- Weigh a price cut against the cost of relisting: more weeks of mortgage payments, utilities and showings, and the chance that the next buyer's appraiser sees the same comps.
Which one do you need?
To set a list price, start with your own comps (see what is my home worth and the home value check) and ask two or three agents for a CMA. Compare the sales they used, not just the price they suggest. A suggested price you cannot tie to specific sales is a guess.
Timing matters here. A CMA tells you where to start before you list. An appraisal usually arrives only after you have a contract, weeks into the deal, when changing course is slower and more expensive. The least costly moment to find out that your price is ahead of the evidence is before you list, not after, and a second opinion from another agent is an inexpensive way to test it.
Hire an appraiser only when you want an independent, documented opinion for your own purposes, and check the license in your state first. Do not expect it to replace the buyer's appraisal. Once you have a range, pricing your home shows how to turn it into a list price. For the buyer's view of the same report, see home inspection and appraisal.
Questions people ask
Is a CMA the same as an appraisal?
No. A CMA is an agent's opinion, usually to help choose a list price. An appraisal is a written report from a licensed appraiser who inspects the home and adjusts for differences from comparable sales.
Does a CMA cost money?
It depends on the agent. Ask before you request one, and ask which sales it will use and what it includes.
Who pays for the appraisal when I sell?
In a financed sale the buyer's lender may require the buyer, as the borrower, to pay for it. Check your contract for any term that changes that.
Can a low appraisal be challenged?
The CFPB says a buyer facing an appraisal well below the offer may want to renegotiate or review the appraiser's work. The request goes through the buyer's lender, so ask your agent how it is handled in your deal.
Sources
- CFPB — What are appraisals and why do I need to look at them?
- CFPB — Why did I receive different valuations during the mortgage loan application process?
- CFPB — My appraisal is less than the sale price. What does that mean for me?
- Appraisal Subcommittee — state compliance and national registries
The $400,000 contract price and $380,000 appraisal are examples chosen for the arithmetic, not data. The CFPB pages are written for borrowers; how a low appraisal plays out for a seller depends on your contract and the buyer's lender. Facts on this page were checked against these sources on November 20, 2026.
Next to read
-
Selling guide
What is my home worth
Online estimates, agent opinions and appraisals compared, plus a way to run your own comps.
-
Selling guide
Pricing your home
Build a list price from comps and competition, then test it against a buyer's monthly payment.
-
Buying guide
Home inspection and appraisal
Who each check is for, what to do with the results, and your right to see the appraisal.