Skip to content
AbodePine

Value

What is my home worth? Four numbers, and how to read each one

Until a buyer and you agree on a price, every figure is an estimate. Here is who produces each one, why they disagree, and how to build your own range.

By AbodePine Editorial Team Updated 6 min read

Online estimate
Computer-generated guess
Agent's opinion
CMA or price opinion
Appraisal
By a licensed appraiser
U.S. prices, Q2 2026
+2.1% in a year
Illustration: a house with a magnifying glass and a price tag

In brief

A home is worth what a buyer will pay on a given day, so before you list you are working with estimates, not a price. An online estimate is a computer's guess, an agent's opinion is built from recent sales, an appraisal is a licensed appraiser's report, and your assessed value is a tax number. They often differ. Start with your own range from recent sales of similar homes, then test it with an agent.

Four numbers people call "value"

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) describes a valuation as an estimate of the amount of money a home may be worth. It names three kinds that come up in a sale or a loan. A fourth, the value your county uses for property tax, is a different thing again. None of them is the sale price. That number does not exist until you and a buyer agree on it.

Four numbers that get called your home's value
NumberWho produces itWhat it rests onGood for
Online estimate (automated valuation model)A computer programHome features and market dataA rough starting point
Agent's price opinionA real estate sales professionalRecent sales of similar homes and the agent's read of the marketChoosing a list price
AppraisalA licensed appraiserAn inspection, with adjustments against comparable salesA formal, documented opinion, such as for a buyer's loan
Assessed valueYour local assessorYour state's and county's tax rulesYour property tax bill, not your sale price

Two valuations of the same house can differ. The CFPB says that is normal: they are estimates, they may use different comps (recent sales of similar homes nearby), and they may be done at different times or for different purposes. When you see two numbers, ask what each one used.

An online estimate has a particular blind spot. A computer cannot see your updated bathroom, the roof that is 20 years old or the damp in the basement. It sees records and statistics. That makes it useful for a first look and weak as a final answer.

Your assessed value is set under your state's rules and can sit above or below what a buyer would pay. If you think it is wrong, see how to appeal a property tax assessment. Your state's property tax page explains how it is set where you live.

Run your own comps

Agents and appraisers both start from comps. You can do a rough version yourself in an evening, and you will then be able to judge what an agent shows you.

  1. Find three to five homes of similar size, age and style that sold in the last three to six months, as close to yours as you can. A county recorder or assessor website, or an agent with access to the local listing service (the MLS), can show sale prices. How much sale data is public varies by state.
  2. Divide each sale price by the home's living area to get a price per square foot.
  3. Drop sales that are different in kind: a gut renovation, a much larger lot, a sale between relatives or in distress.
  4. Multiply your home's living area by the lowest and highest price per square foot that remain. That is your rough range.
  5. Adjust by judgment for what square footage misses: condition, updates, lot, garage, bedrooms and bathrooms.

Here is the arithmetic with example numbers, not any real market. Three comps sold for $410,000 at 2,000 square feet, $380,000 at 1,900 and $420,000 at 2,100. That is $205, $200 and $200 per square foot. Your home has 1,800 square feet: 1,800 × $200 = $360,000 and 1,800 × $205 = $369,000. The rough range before adjustments is $360,000 to $369,000.

The home value check runs this arithmetic from comps you enter. It is a worksheet, not an appraisal.

Check it against the market trend

Old sales go stale when prices move. The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) House Price Index tracks price changes in repeat sales and refinancings of the same properties. Its latest quarterly release, published August 25, 2026, shows U.S. house prices up 2.1% between the second quarter of 2025 and the second quarter of 2026, and up 0.3% from the first to the second quarter of 2026 (seasonally adjusted). FHFA's next quarterly release is scheduled for November 24, 2026.

That is a national number, and it measures change, not level: it cannot tell you what your home is worth, only which way prices have moved. Your neighborhood may have moved more or less. FHFA publishes the index for states, metro areas, counties and ZIP codes as well. If a comp sold months ago, you can age it with a local figure. Example: if the local index rose 1% since a $400,000 comp sold, the comp is worth about $400,000 × 1.01 = $404,000 today. Treat that as a nudge, not a correction.

When you need a firmer number

If you are choosing a list price, ask two or three agents for a comparative market analysis and ask which sales each used. CMA vs. appraisal explains the difference and who orders each one. Pricing your home turns the range into a list price.

If you want an independent, documented opinion, hire a licensed appraiser. States license and certify appraisers, and the federal Appraisal Subcommittee keeps a national registry of them. A buyer's lender will usually order its own appraisal if the buyer finances, so yours does not replace it.

Once you have a range, put it next to what you owe. With an example value of $365,000 and a mortgage payoff of $250,000, the gap is $115,000 before commission, closing costs and any repairs. That is not what you would walk away with. Seller closing costs and net proceeds shows how to subtract the rest.

Questions people ask

Are online home value estimates accurate?

The CFPB describes an automated valuation model as a computer-generated value that uses mathematical models of home features and market data. It is an estimate, and two estimates of one home can differ because they use different comps. Use it as a starting point and check the sales behind it.

Is my assessed value what my home is worth?

Not necessarily. The assessor sets it under your state's tax rules for your tax bill, and it can differ from what a buyer would pay. Treat it as one more data point.

Should I pay for an appraisal before I list?

Many sellers start with their own comps and two or three agents' opinions instead. An appraisal is worth considering when you want an independent, documented opinion. A buyer's lender will order its own appraisal for a financed purchase.

How do I find what nearby homes sold for?

Try your county recorder or assessor website, or ask an agent to pull recent sales from the MLS. Whether sale prices are public varies by state.

Sources

The three comps, the 1,800 square feet and the 1% local change are examples chosen for the arithmetic, not data from any market. The FHFA figures are from the release of August 25, 2026. Facts on this page were checked against these sources on November 20, 2026.